Manhattan GMAT Forums Forum Index

Reply to topic
qualified or not?
Hei
Guest


Reply with quote
Jone Ashia'sXYZ is one of the 5 best fictions ever written by Indians.
vs.
Jone Ashia'sXYZ is one of the 5 best fictions ever written by an Indian.

XYZ is written by one Indian - Jone, but at the same time, the sentence is talking about the 5 best fictions written by Indians as well...
Is it necessary to qualify? Or both of them correct with no different meaning?
Ron Purewal
MGMAT STAFF

Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 2219

Reply with quote
preferred usage (here in the US, at least) dictates the latter usage: ...written by an indian.
the idea is that the first wording doesn't make it clear that the books were authored by individuals, but the second does.

by the way, you can't pluralize 'fiction' (again, at least not here in the US - i don't know about commonwealth english): fiction is an uncountable mass noun, much like furniture, laundry, or silverware (think about the way you'd talk about more than one of those items, too, to make the point more clear).
you'd have to say 'works of fiction' or some other such construction.
qualified or not?
All times are GMT - 5 Hours  
Page 1 of 1  

  
  
 Reply to topic