Manhattan GMAT Forums Forum Index

Reply to topic
Is the postive integer n an odd integer
BeatGMAT
Guest


Reply with quote
Is the positive integer 'n' an odd integer

1. n + 4 is a prime number
2. n + 3 is not a prime number

It feels like this might be an easy problem and I get
(1) as:
We are given n + 4 is a prime number. We know that all prime numbers greater starting with 5 (as n is a positive integer, it has to start with 1) are odd, and an odd number – 4 is odd, hence sufficient

(2) I tested this statement with 2 values, 3 & 6, where both n + 3 are not prime numbers, hence insufficient

Is there a better way to test (2) ?
Guest
Guest


Reply with quote
Isn't statement 2 sufficient because if we test it with 3, we get n equals 0? But according to the stem of the question, n is a positive integer
Guest



Reply with quote
Guest wrote:
Isn't statement 2 sufficient because if we test it with 3, we get n equals 0? But according to the stem of the question, n is a positive integer


I am sorry I forgot to include the answer - ONLY 1 is sufficient, 2 is not
Kamlesh
Guest


Reply with quote
we can eliminate such statement that say sumthin is not equal 2 sumthing .......... it might be equal to infinity :lol:
Ron Purewal
MGMAT STAFF

Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 2295

Reply with quote
Guest wrote:
Isn't statement 2 sufficient because if we test it with 3, we get n equals 0? But according to the stem of the question, n is a positive integer


you can't use irrelevant cases to test for sufficiency. if the stem states that n must be a positive integer, then you must ignore all cases in which n turns out NOT to be a positive integer.
or:
since statement (2) is about n + 3, not n, you only need to think about cases in which n + 3 is at least 4 (because n is at least 1).

--

since it's data sufficiency, the question of whether n is odd is equivalent to the question of whether n + 3 is odd (they're just opposites: if one is odd, the other is even, and vice versa).
so, just pick two NON-prime numbers for n + 3 - one even, one odd - and that will show insufficiency.
if n + 3 = 10 (not prime), then n = 7. odd.
if n + 3 = 9 (not prime), then n = 6. not odd.
insufficient.
Is the postive integer n an odd integer
All times are GMT - 5 Hours  
Page 1 of 1  

  
  
 Reply to topic