Manhattan GMAT Forums Forum Index

Reply to topic
VIC's Chapter 4: Formulas Problem Set quest 10
kimd6746
Guest


Reply with quote
Hello,

I'm totally confused by question 10 in pg 61's Problem Set. The answer says that the relationship between Wa=4Wb and A=256. Why should 4 be multiplied to Wb when the question says that "the team won 1/4 as many games in year B as it did in year A....". Shouldn't it read Wa=.25Wb? What am I missing?
Ron Purewal
MGMAT STAFF

Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 2207

Reply with quote
nope, you've got it backwards.

here's the best way to figure it out: just think about which of the two values is bigger, and create an equation reflecting that choice.

in this case, the statement you've quoted definitely means that the team won more games in year A. therefore, you must write an equation that makes Wa a bigger number than Wb.
check the possible equations you could write:
Wa = 4Wb --> good (Wa is bigger)
Wb = 4Wa --> bad (Wb is bigger)
Wa = 0.25Wb --> bad (Wa is smaller)
Wb = 0.25Wa --> good (Wb is smaller)

this is ultimately easier than trying to memorize algebraic translations of every possible combination of words under the sun. but hopefully you've learned the following lesson: just because a number is closer to a given word in a statement, doesn't mean that number will appear next to the variable representing that word in the equation you eventually write.

i hope that last sentence makes sense; it's definitely one of those things that's easier to say out loud than to type on a forum.
Re: VIC's Chapter 4: Formulas Problem Set quest 10
UPA
Guest


Reply with quote
kimd6746 wrote:
Hello,

I'm totally confused by question 10 in pg 61's Problem Set. The answer says that the relationship between Wa=4Wb and A=256. Why should 4 be multiplied to Wb when the question says that "the team won 1/4 as many games in year B as it did in year A....". Shouldn't it read Wa=.25Wb? What am I missing?


what is VIC's?
Stacey Koprince
MGMAT STAFF

Joined: 06 Mar 2007
Posts: 2589
Location: San Francisco
Reply with quote
The full name of the book is Equations, Inequalities and VICs. VIC is a specific technique for solving certain kinds of algebra problems.
VIC's Chapter 4: Formulas Problem Set quest 10
kimd6746
Guest


Reply with quote
I'm still having trouble with this question. The answer in the book is as follows:

Let a = comp edge yr A
Let b = comp edge yr B

Wa = 4 Wb
A = 256B

It then tells you to cross multiple the following algebraic expression given the Comp Edge formula of W^3/L^2.

((4Wb)^3)/(La^2) = (256Wb^3)/(Lb^2)
begats:
64WbLa^2 = 256Wb^3La^2
begats:
Lb^2 = 4La^2
Lb = 2La

My question is, why wasn't 256Wb raised to the 3rd power like 4Wb^3 (eg. 64WbLa^2) has? I know raising 256 to the 3rd power will give you a crazy number, but on principle shouldn't you follow the same power rules on both sides?
Re: VIC's Chapter 4: Formulas Problem Set quest 10
Ron Purewal
MGMAT STAFF

Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 2207

Reply with quote
kimd6746 wrote:
My question is, why wasn't 256Wb raised to the 3rd power like 4Wb^3 (eg. 64WbLa^2) has? I know raising 256 to the 3rd power will give you a crazy number, but on principle shouldn't you follow the same power rules on both sides?


1)
standard order of operations says no: if i write the expression 256w^3, then that means you should first cube 'w', and then multiply the resulting quantity by 256.

2)
moreover, you know that you are multiplying last year's formula by 256. this means that the multiplication by 256 must be done last, anyway - regardless of order of operations - because the context of the problem makes it clear that you are calculating the formula for last year, and then multiplying it by 256.

make sense?
VIC's Chapter 4: Formulas Problem Set quest 10
All times are GMT - 5 Hours  
Page 1 of 1  

  
  
 Reply to topic