Author 
Message 
ruben

Post subject: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Mon Aug 13, 2007 10:18 pm 


Hi,
I want to thank you for the great job you guys do with the forum and the website!!
Ok, here is the question. The information given in the question, PS and QR are parallel and the answer n* 1 (PS=QR), don't seem to define strictly a parallelogram .In other words, would a square still have 2 parallel sides that are also equal?
ThankS!!!!
In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR. Is PQRS a parallelogram?
(1) PS = QR
(2) PQ = RS
Statement (1) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not sufficient.
Statement (2) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not sufficient.
Both statements TOGETHER are sufficient, but NEITHER one ALONE is sufficient.
EACH statement ALONE is sufficient.
Statements (1) and (2) TOGETHER are NOT sufficient.
A parallelogram is a quadrilateral in which both pairs of opposite sides are parallel. The opposite sides of a parallelogram also have equal length.
(1) SUFFICIENT: We know from the question stem that opposite sides PS and QR are parallel, while this statement tells us that they also have equal lengths. The opposite sides PQ and RS must also be parallel and equal in length. This is the definition of a parallelogram, so the answer to the question is "Yes."
(2) INSUFFICIENT: We know from the question stem that opposite sides PS and QR are parallel, but have no information about their respective lengths. This statement tells us that the opposite sides PQ and RS are equal in length, but we don’t know their respective angles; they might be parallel, or they might not be. According to the information given, PQRS could be a trapezoid with PS not equal to QR. On the other hand, PQRS could be a parallelogram with PS = QR. The answer to the question is uncertain.
The correct answer is A.





ANADI

Post subject: parallelogram or trapezoid Posted: Tue Aug 14, 2007 11:11 am 


(1) PS = QR
PS=QR, means there are 2 parrallel lines of same length, so if you join there respective ends , those 2 lines are alos going to be parallel and equal length. This is so because we can prove that if we draw one diagnol, the 2 resulting triangles will be similar triangle (They have 2 equal sides and the angle between them equal).
(2) PQ = RS
This can clearly be a trapezoid, but may or may not be parallelogram. Since PQ=RS, we can prove 2 sides to be equal and one angle to be equal but not the angle between 2 equal sides, so triangles cannot be similar.
Hope it helps, since it can be completely clear with diagrams which I can't draw here.





StaceyKoprince

Post subject: Posted: Sat Aug 18, 2007 1:14 pm 


ManhattanGMAT Staff 

Posts: 7769 Location: San Francisco

Hey, ruben, thanks for the vote of confidence. You list this problem as "GMAT Test 1"  we actually need the name of the author / source for copyright reasons before instructors can comment. Can you tell me where this is from? (I'm guessing it's one of ours, but I have to make sure.) Thanks!
_________________ Stacey Koprince Instructor Director of Online Community ManhattanGMAT





Guest

Post subject: Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2007 12:31 am 


Stacey,
It is one of the MGAMT test. I will make sure to say where the questions come from from now on!
Thanks
Ruben





dbernst

Post subject: Posted: Thu Sep 06, 2007 10:44 am 


ManhattanGMAT Staff 

Posts: 301

Ruben, let me know whether I am interpreting your original question correctly. I think you are questioning whether Statement (1) alone is sufficient since the figure could also be a square. If this is the case, the answer is that a square IS a parallelogram  it is simply a special type of parallelogram. Just as a parallelogram is a special type of quadrilateral (4 sided figure), both rectangles and squares are special types of parallelograms (and, of course, special types of quadrilaterals!).
dan





goelmohit2002

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2009 3:55 pm 


Students 

Posts: 226

OE said = (1) SUFFICIENT: We know from the question stem that opposite sides PS and QR are parallel, while this statement tells us that they also have equal lengths. The opposite sides PQ and RS must also be parallel and equal in length. This is the definition of a parallelogram, so the answer to the question is "Yes."
Can someone please why the highlighted(bold) one is correct ? How to prove the same ? How can we come to the highlighted conclusion from the statement 1 alone ?





Ben Ku

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Thu Aug 13, 2009 2:36 pm 


ManhattanGMAT Staff 

Posts: 818

A parallelogram is any quadrilateral where both pairs of opposite sides are parallel (and turns out that they also have equal length).
There are many different kinds of parallelograms:  A parallelogram where all four sides have the same length is called a rhombus.  A parallelogram where all four angles are right angles is called a rectangle.  A parallelogram where all four sides are the same length, and all four angles are right angles is called a square. So square is one kind of parallelogram.
Now, examining the question you pose, if PS is parallel to QR, and they are the same length, then we can determine that the other two sides (PQ and RS) are also parallel and the same length. You can try to draw two parallel lines with the same length, and you see that when you connect them, you'll always get a parallelogram.
The geometric proof uses a diagonal (for example, PR).  Knowing that given parallel lines, alternate interior angles have the same measure, you know SPR and PRQ have the same measure.  Comparing triangles SPR and PRQ, we know that PR in triangle SPR is congruent to PR in triangle PRQ, since it's the same segment. We know that PS and QR are congruent (given in the statement).  Triangles SPR and PRQ are congruent (using SAS). Because the triangles are congruent, the sides PQ and RS are parallel and have the same length.
I hope that helps.
_________________ Ben Ku Instructor ManhattanGMAT





goelmohit2002

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Thu Aug 13, 2009 2:45 pm 


Students 

Posts: 226

bku wrote: A parallelogram is any quadrilateral where both pairs of opposite sides are parallel (and turns out that they also have equal length).
There are many different kinds of parallelograms:  A parallelogram where all four sides have the same length is called a rhombus.  A parallelogram where all four angles are right angles is called a rectangle.  A parallelogram where all four sides are the same length, and all four angles are right angles is called a square. So square is one kind of parallelogram.
Now, examining the question you pose, if PS is parallel to QR, and they are the same length, then we can determine that the other two sides (PQ and RS) are also parallel and the same length. You can try to draw two parallel lines with the same length, and you see that when you connect them, you'll always get a parallelogram.
The geometric proof uses a diagonal (for example, PR).  Knowing that given parallel lines, alternate interior angles have the same measure, you know SPR and PRQ have the same measure.  Comparing triangles SPR and PRQ, we know that PR in triangle SPR is congruent to PR in triangle PRQ, since it's the same segment. We know that PS and QR are congruent (given in the statement).  Triangles SPR and PRQ are congruent (using SAS). Because the triangles are congruent, the sides PQ and RS are parallel and have the same length.
I hope that helps. Thanks a lot Ben !





Ben Ku

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Tue Aug 18, 2009 5:06 pm 


ManhattanGMAT Staff 

Posts: 818

you're welcome!
_________________ Ben Ku Instructor ManhattanGMAT





gorav.s

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Wed Sep 16, 2009 3:19 pm 


Course Students 

Posts: 25

This is easy and clear guys  statement 1 is sufficient. Here you know both parallel sides are also equal . This is a necessary condition to declare it a parallelogram.
Statement 2,  question just says two lines PS and QR are parallel . Assume one line PS is bigger and other line QR is smaller. now still RS = PQ can happen and figue will not be a parallelogram but a trapezium.
I cannot draw the fig here , but vizualize it and you will understand hence answer = A.





Ben Ku

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 3:54 am 


ManhattanGMAT Staff 

Posts: 818

gorav.s, thanks for your response. I think that often questions that may seem to be "easy and clear" can be confusing (especially under the testtaking pressures) if the foundations in defining these geometric terms are not there. So the key is to be absolutely confident about the terms and their related properties.
_________________ Ben Ku Instructor ManhattanGMAT





its4christian

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Mon Mar 29, 2010 3:41 pm 


Course Students 

Posts: 10

hi all, gorav.s says that statement 2 is stating the PS and QR are parallel, but doesn't it says that PS and QR have the same length?
(2) PQ = RS
If that's the case then you cannot assume PS will be bigger than QR, so it should be a sufficient statment as well, correct?
Thank you Chris





Ben Ku

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2010 7:49 pm 


ManhattanGMAT Staff 

Posts: 818

its4christian wrote: hi all, gorav.s says that statement 2 is stating the PS and QR are parallel, but doesn't it says that PS and QR have the same length?
(2) PQ = RS
If that's the case then you cannot assume PS will be bigger than QR, so it should be a sufficient statment as well, correct?
Thank you Chris It is possible for PS to be bigger than QR, if PQRS is an isosceles trapezoid (the bases are PS and QR, the legs are PQ and RS).
_________________ Ben Ku Instructor ManhattanGMAT





its4christian

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2010 8:59 pm 


Course Students 

Posts: 10

I got it! Thank you Ben!
Christian





Ben Ku

Post subject: Re: In the quadrilateral PQRS, side PS is parallel to side QR Posted: Wed Apr 28, 2010 11:04 pm 


ManhattanGMAT Staff 

Posts: 818

you're welcome!
_________________ Ben Ku Instructor ManhattanGMAT





